Tideify
Back to Blog
Tools10 min read

The Only Shopify Apps Your Store Actually Needs in 2025

The Shopify App Store has over 8,000 apps. Most stores install too many, slowing down their site and complicating management. Here are the apps that actually matter, organized by business priority.

Email Marketing (Essential)

Top Choice: Klaviyo

  • Best for: Stores doing $10K+/month
  • Cost: Free up to 250 contacts, then $20-500/month
  • Why: Industry-leading segmentation, automation, and analytics. ROI typically 30-40x investment.

Alternative: Omnisend

  • Best for: Smaller stores
  • Cost: Free up to 250 contacts, then $16+/month
  • Why: Good balance of features and affordability for growing stores.

Skip: Generic email tools. E-commerce-specific platforms deliver 3-5x better results.

Reviews (Essential)

Top Choice: Judge.me

  • Cost: Free (paid plans $15/month)
  • Why: Excellent features on free plan, easy setup, great support. Photo reviews, Q&A, and Google integration included.

Alternative: Loox

  • Cost: $9.99-$299/month
  • Why: Beautiful photo review displays, excellent for fashion/lifestyle brands.

Skip: Overpriced review apps that charge $50+/month for basic functionality.

SEO & Site Optimization (Important)

Top Choice: Plug in SEO

  • Cost: Free (Pro at $20/month)
  • Why: Automatically identifies and helps fix SEO issues. Great for non-technical users.

For Advanced Users: Schema Plus

  • Cost: $9.99/month
  • Why: Adds comprehensive structured data for better search results appearance.

Skip: Expensive SEO apps that promise magical ranking improvements. Focus on solid technical SEO basics instead.

Page Builder (Situational)

Top Choice: PageFly (for most stores)

  • Cost: Free to $99/month
  • Why: Powerful drag-and-drop builder, great for landing pages without theme limitations.

Alternative: Shogun

  • Cost: $39-$399/month
  • Why: More premium option with better design templates and A/B testing.

When to skip: If your theme has good customization options, you might not need a page builder at all.

Upsells & Cross-sells (High ROI)

Top Choice: Rebuy

  • Cost: $99-999/month (based on revenue)
  • Why: AI-powered recommendations, post-purchase upsells, smart cart. Typically increases AOV by 15-30%.

Budget Alternative: In-Cart Upsell

  • Cost: $19.99/month
  • Why: Simple, effective cart upsells without the high cost.

Skip: Apps that destroy your site speed with heavy scripts. Ensure any upsell app is well-coded.

Subscriptions (If Applicable)

Top Choice: Recharge

  • Cost: $99-499/month + 1% of subscription revenue
  • Why: Industry standard for subscriptions. Robust features, reliable, good analytics.

Alternative: Seal Subscriptions

  • Cost: Free to $9.90/month
  • Why: Great for stores just starting with subscriptions. Much more affordable.

Skip: Building subscriptions from scratch. The apps pay for themselves quickly.

Analytics (Important)

Essential: Google Analytics 4

  • Cost: Free
  • Why: Essential baseline analytics. Set up properly with e-commerce tracking enabled.

Next Level: Triple Whale

  • Cost: $129-999/month
  • Why: Simplified analytics dashboard, attribution tracking, key metrics at a glance.

For Facebook Ads: Northbeam

  • Cost: $500+/month
  • Why: Best-in-class attribution for brands spending heavily on paid social.

Skip: Expensive analytics tools if you're not actively using data to make decisions.

Customer Support (Growing Stores)

Top Choice: Gorgias

  • Cost: $10-750/month
  • Why: Purpose-built for e-commerce, integrates with all your tools, automation features.

Alternative: Richpanel

  • Cost: $30-300/month
  • Why: Good for brands needing self-service customer portal.

Skip: Generic support tools like Zendesk. E-commerce-specific platforms work better for stores.

Inventory & Fulfillment (Scaling)

Top Choice: ShipStation

  • Cost: $9.99-159.99/month
  • Why: Multi-carrier shipping, automation, excellent for scaling operations.

Alternative: Shopify Shipping

  • Cost: Free (pay for shipping)
  • Why: Built-in, no additional software, good rates for U.S. merchants.

Skip: Expensive fulfillment software until you're doing 1,000+ orders/month.

Security & Trust

Essential: Shopify's Built-in SSL

  • Cost: Free
  • Why: Handles all security basics.

Add-on: Signifyd

  • Cost: Pay per order protected
  • Why: Fraud protection for higher-risk stores. Pays for itself by preventing chargebacks.

Apps to Generally Avoid

1. Too Many "All-in-One" Apps These usually do many things poorly rather than one thing well.

2. Redundant Apps Don't install three different popup builders or review apps. Pick one and use it well.

3. Abandoned Apps Check last update date. Apps not updated in 12+ months may break with Shopify updates.

4. Apps With Poor Reviews < 4.0 stars or consistent complaints about support = avoid.

5. Speed-Killing Apps Run speed tests before and after installing apps. Remove any that significantly slow your site.

App Audit Checklist

Every quarter, review your apps:

  • ✅ Is it being actively used?
  • ✅ Does it provide measurable ROI?
  • ✅ Is it negatively impacting site speed?
  • ✅ Can native Shopify features replace it?
  • ✅ Are there better alternatives now available?

Remove apps that don't pass this test.

Sample App Stack by Business Stage

New Store ($0-10K/month)

  • Email: Omnisend (free plan)
  • Reviews: Judge.me (free)
  • SEO: Plug in SEO (free)
  • Total: $0/month

Growing Store ($10K-100K/month)

  • Email: Klaviyo ($50-150/month)
  • Reviews: Judge.me ($15/month)
  • SEO: Plug in SEO + Schema Plus ($30/month)
  • Upsells: In-Cart Upsell ($20/month)
  • Page Builder: PageFly ($24/month)
  • Total: $139-219/month

Established Store ($100K+/month)

  • Email: Klaviyo ($200-500/month)
  • Reviews: Loox ($100/month)
  • SEO: Full suite ($50/month)
  • Upsells: Rebuy ($100-500/month)
  • Page Builder: Shogun ($99/month)
  • Analytics: Triple Whale ($129/month)
  • Support: Gorgias ($300/month)
  • Total: $978-1,678/month

The Real Cost of Too Many Apps

Beyond monthly fees, excessive apps cost you:

  • Site speed - Each app adds code that slows loading
  • Management time - More complexity = more maintenance
  • Integration issues - Apps conflict with each other
  • Decision paralysis - Too many tools prevents mastering any

Best practice: Start minimal. Add apps only when you have a specific need and can measure the impact.

Need help optimizing your Shopify app stack? Tideify can audit your current setup, identify what's working (and what's not), and implement high-ROI tools that actually move the needle for your business. Contact us for a free app stack audit. ```

Need Help with Your Shopify Store?

Our team of Shopify experts can help you implement these strategies and more. Get in touch for a free consultation.

Get Started